Items in alt.philosophy.checkmate

Subject:Re: Agnosticism is the only logical answer to the existence of a God
Date:Tue, 29 Jul 2014 16:55:51 -0700
From:Checkmate <LunaticFringe@The.Edge>
Newsgroups:alt.agnosticism,alt.atheism,alt.checkmate,alt.christianity,alt.philosophy.checkmate,alt.usenet.kooks
Warning!  Always wear ANSI approved safety goggles when reading posts by 
Checkmate!

First  check out what felix_unger said:
 

> 
> On 28-July-2014 5:14 AM, Sir Gregory Hall, Esq. wrote:
> > On Sun, 27 Jul 2014 11:37:32 -0700, Checkmate <LunaticFringe@The.Edge>
> > wrote:
> >> First check out what Sir Gregory Hall, Esq. said:
> >>> The Checkmate bleated . . .
> >> Again, you proudly display your ignorance as if it were a record-
> >> breaking turd.  "Taking a stance" is only admirable if you're capable of
> >> demonstrating a credible reason for taking it.  Atheists look at the
> >> world in all it's complexity, and assume that life developed out of a
> >> mind-boggling number of fortuitous events that brought miraculous order
> >> out of chaos, when the universal norm is for order to deteriorate into
> >> disorder (IE: entropy).
> > Good start!
> >
> >> Those who believe in (place your favorite fairy tale "religion" here),
> >> are convinced that life was instantly created by a magic Sky Daddy out
> >> of clay, or a rib, or some other such mythical nonsense, when scientific
> >> evidence clearly shows that not to be the case.
> > Wrong!  Again you insist on reading the Bible literally. You refuse
> > to believe that the Bible is easily reconcilable with science provided
> > it is considered allegory in many instances where it is obviously
> > allegory and story telling to the illiterates of the day.
> >
> >> The Ancients had an excuse... they were ignorant and mostly uneducated.
> >> The ones who were responsible for promoting and exploiting the myths
> >> were the ones who quickly figured out that it was the easiest way to
> >> control the ignorant and gullible herds (Constantine et al).
> > You are cynic. You assume control while education and enlightenment
> > was the real reason. You think evil thoughts because Satan holds
> > sway in your world.
> >
> >> I've asked you this before, and you've always failed to answer it:  If
> >> you had been born into a culture that espoused a different religion,
> >> such as Islam or Hinduism for example, would you have ever held the
> >> Christian beliefs that you're so convinced are "The Way" today?
> > The answer to that is "I don't know?" I haven't answered heretofore
> > for precisely that reason - your question is stupid and you know it.
> 
> It's not. you're dodging the question. ppl will believe as they are 
> taught and raised to believe, unless or until they come to believe 
> differently for whatever reason
> 
> >
> >> Are all
> >> the children who grow up in those cultures and embrace what they were
> >> told, doomed to burn eternally in your mythical hell?  What kind of God
> >> would will that upon his creations?
> > My God created mankind with a mind that can make choices.
> 
> the only choice Christianity offers is believe or be dammed.
> 
> > A mind that
> > is easily educated. My God expects me to use that mind to make
> > sensible choices between good and evil. Islam, for example is evil
> > as evidenced by their beheading people who won't believe as they do.
> 
> Islam is a cancer on the modern world
> 
> >> As an agnostic, I believe there very well could be a God of some sort.
> >> It's no more of a stretch to accept that a God COULD exist, than it is
> >> to accept that the universe we live in DOES exist.  The conundrum lies
> >> in trying to explain where either came from in the first place.
> > You are so stupid! You claim to be agnostic yet you don't even
> > understand the definition of agnostic. Here:
> >
> > ag·nos·tic
> > ag'nästik
> > noun
> > 1.
> > a person who believes that nothing is known or can be known of the
> > existence or nature of God or of anything beyond material phenomena;
> > a person who claims neither faith nor disbelief in God.
> > synonyms: skeptic, doubter, doubting Thomas, cynic;
> >
> > So, if you understood the definition of agnostic you would realize
> > you are NOT one because you say, "As an agnostic, I believe there very
> > well could be a God of some sort."  That is NOT being an agnostic,
> > dude! If there could very well be a god then that belies the agnostic
> > belief that the existence of a god is not knowable.
> 
> what part of "a person who claims neither faith nor disbelief in God" 
> did you not understand? very few definitions mean just one thing only. I 
> have had great difficulty convincing atheists to accept this regarding 
> the definition of evidence, and generally they stubbornly refuse to 
> accept evidence means anything other than something that proves 
> something else. but I digress.. agnosticism is commonly understood to 
> mean neither belief in the existence of God, or a belief that God does 
> not exist. someone who believes there may be a God is what we refer to 
> as agnostic. if we don't 'know' God exists and we don't 'know' God 
> doesn't exist (and how can we know anyway?), then how can we believe 
> with any certainty either way? all we can do is put our faith in one 
> belief or the other, or adopt the sensible and rational approach and 
> believe there may be a God or not.
> 
> >> Evolutionary science doesn't disprove the existence of a God, it just
> >> contradicts the ludicrous claims as to the methodology that a God may
> >> have used to create life as we presently know it.
> > Again, dude, think *allegory*!  Only stupid-assed *fundies* take
> > the Bible literally.
> >
> >> As a Christian, your set of beliefs has been shown to be based entirely
> >> on anecdotal "evidence" and stories that smack of mythology.  In this
> >> era of scientific enlightenment, it boggles my mind to see so many
> >> otherwise-intelligent people such as yourself, still clinging to such
> >> antiquated and tenuous arguments.
> > If you refuse to read, C.S. Lewis' "Mere Christianity" then STFU as
> > you are too ignorant to make the aforementioned claims. Just persist
> > in your ignorance of the scientific viewpoint of Christianity as it
> > seems to make you comfortable in your abject and hopeless ignorance.
> >
> >> Personally, I believe that there probably is a Creator.  I prefer that
> >> term over "God," because the term God means many different things to
> >> many different people.  As an agnostic, I can't assign any specific
> >> attributes to define who... or even what this Creator might be, and this
> >> is where I take great exception to any religion that claims to "know"
> >> such a Creator, or what this Creator might "want" from us.
> > Semantic! I, too, am comfortable with *Creator* or *Father*.
> >
> >> People fear death, yet they know it's inevitable.  They want desperately
> >> to believe in a "heaven," where they'll go and live happily ever after.
> >> It's a comforting concept, but not supported the slightest bit by
> >> present knowledge or reason.
> >>
> >> To those who claim they "know" there's a God/Creator, as well as those
> >> who claim they "know" there isn't, I'd suggest that the methodology that
> >> brought you to that conclusion is flawed.
> > Faith, my man, faith. God created us to be able to embrace faith.
> >

I knew there HAD to be somebody else out there who "gets it".

-- 
Checkmate
KotAGoR XXXIV
AUK Hammer of Thor award, Feb. 2012
co-winner, Pierre Salinger Memorial Hook, 
Line & Sinker award, May 2001            
Copyright © 2014 
all rights reserved


"The Man Who Destroyed Fakey and Made Him Have a Total Meltdown"

"I don't have narcissism, I *earned* my right to look down upon others."
-Fakey  Message-ID: <16dfbb9fba6cc9127a2983e7b0caaad5@dizum.com>

"I keep telling you, I'm straight."
-Fakey  Message-ID: <a2a92134fb8dafded750dd34305b1654@dizum.com>

"My... my dad would get drunk... really, really drunk. And he'd smoke
a lot of pot. When he'd take off his shirt and start rubbing his belly
with his hand, I knew what that meant. I would usually try going
outside to get away from him, but we lived out in the middle of
nowhere, there was no getting away from him, there was nowhere to go!"
-Fakey  Message-ID: <8c4b752d97211b2603538d2f139e40bb@dizum.com>